I feel for that hoax too, back in 1997! The one where you walk around the tree in front of the castle, collect every coin in the game, ride the volcano merry-go-round fifty times, then talk to Yoshi, and Luigi jumps out of the waterfall to meet you!
Odyssey 2. Galaxy was a cool concept, but they already went back to that well. I'd love to see what they could do with another go at the Odyssey formula.
I don't have many ideas but I feel like there would be sense Galaxy has been tried twice in different ways and Odyssey has only been done once so not only can they apply old ideas to new things they also still have more room for new ideas to try
They could keep the formula exactly the same, just add new things to mind control and it would be great.
If they ever did a Odyssey 2, the likely won't go this route, but like how Pauline is in one stage, it would be interesting to visit other characters in their own stages. Like visit Wario at Wario Inc, Princess Daisy in Sarasaland, meet any of the kings from Super Mario 3.
The first game already went to the moon. So the observatory isn't out of the question. Or go further, as Samus is canonical to the Mario universe.
I’m inclined to agree but they also went back to odyssey with things like bowsers fury and super mario 3d world, which were both done excellently imo. tbh i think i just want a whole new game, not because i didn’t like the owners, but because they have proved they can handle a new concept and excel with it, so something new would be even better (hopefully)
I don’t know why everyone complains about this, I had literally no problem with the filler moons. It’s really only bothersome if you are going for 100%. I think it’s great that it basically has a “choose your own difficulty” where you only need a certain amount, so if you want to challenge yourself for a tough moon you can, or if you want you can get some easier ones instead
Ok well I enjoyed the shit out of Odyssey and so did a lot of other people, so maybe that’s just your personal preference and comparing it to the older games instead of just taking this game as it is
Well, think of how many points a moon has. Two, right? Now think of how many a star has: Five. That’s 2.5x more points. I hope now you understand why they’re so great
That SOUNDS right, and yet this is the very first time that I feel a Collectathon Mario game is **fun** to play.
Mario 64 was in the genre's infancy so a lot could could be forgiven, but by the time Mario Sunshine came out we already had plenty of better games that felt a lot better to play, from the high-profile Spyro games to even smaller titles like that Toy Story 2 game. Sunshine had no excuse to be so badly executed as it was, for being the successor of the game that invented the genre.
I also found Galaxy a slog to play through. They insisted on kicking you out of a level every time you collected something, reshuffling the level time after time and destroying whatever sense of exploration I might have had (this is a problem for the other titles too, but by Galaxy's era I have no idea why they couldn't have that sorted out yet so it's even more glaring), and in general behind their gimmick the places you explore feel unimaginative and even depressing to hang out in. The occasional dark sky is fine, but Galaxy definitely lacked the variety of settings that other Mario games have. I skipped Galaxy 2 because I didn't see the point.
Say what you will about Odyssey, but it's the first time EVER in my long gamer career that started back on the NES that I can honestly say a Mario game is the best kind of Collectathon on the market, present or past.
Maybe 8 unique stars have the potential to actually be better designed but OH BOY they really haven't lived up to that potential before Odyssey.
Super Mario Galactic Odyssey
Odyssey movement, Cappy, capturing enemies but you’re on planetoids. Some galaxies are kingdom sized with tons of stars and then there are some smaller Galaxy 1/2 sized galaxies. Both can mess around with planetoids and gravity manipulation
And maybe X and Y could each individually control Cappy and luma for spin jump. It would be cute seeing luma carry Cappy around too
Galaxy 1 and 2 for that matter were/are may favorite games of all time. I have such great nestlogia for them and revisit them once a year. That being said, odyssey was just as phenomenal, and deserves a sequel, so I agree.
Nostalgia* Sorry for making the agregious mistake, that is a typo. Thank you so much for pointing out this major spelling error. I present you this trophy for this incredible achievement.
👍
I'm sure that was the case. /s
Dis you? https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/wsahmf/why_are_you_on_reddit_right_now/ikzg6kv?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share&context=3
I'm trying to 100% galaxy on the switch and that's the one thing i really can't stand about it, I'm never able to see what I need to. Not even the camera for N64 annoyed me this badly.
Yeah, agreed. I got about half way before giving up in frustration. We're spoilt by modern 3D games that always give full camera control with a right stick.
Galaxy 3. Everything was grandiose in the Galaxy series that it made my kid and adult brains explode with joy. So over the top, so cinematic, it was awesome
Damn between a Mario and Luigi on the Switch and Odyssey 2 would be such a tough call for me. Fucking adore that series but only one is realistic probably.
Nooooooo. Galaxy is linear start to finish levels with a bunch of upside down small planet shit. This person is asking for a darkest side of the moon odyssey.
Galaxy 3. The children have had their time, but now it’s time for the men to have their turn. Just kidding lol. Odyssey was really cool, but I think that it’s about time that Galaxy gets to have a comeback.
Galaxy 3. Galaxy 2 is one of my favorite games of all time, with 1 being not very far behind. To be honest, I don't really care that much about captures in retrospect. Gravity however, was a very fun mechanic to me that I would love to see return as the main gimmick.
Galaxy 3 without a doubt. Its just one of those series that should be wrapped up in a trilogy, with a bow on top.
And if they do ever make Galaxy 3, I hope they add Birdo since they added Yoshi in 2.
Both have their merits. Gakaxy 3 would have a lot more variety, but more linearity, most likely. Odyssey 2 would have more substantial, open levels, but fewer of them. I personally would prefer Galaxy 3 because I think Odyssey doesn't do as good a job of making main objectives feel satisfying, plus I think that the Galaxy games have some of the best bosses in 3D Mario.
Odyssey with a hub world instead of the balloon. Take the best and mix it with the best. More unlockables and more secrets, collect everything and get a different final boss.
Odyssey is trash in comparison to Galaxy 2, facts. Galaxy 2 just has way more galaxies aka kingdoms to explore. And the gameplay is p similar so Galaxy 2 easily wins which means Galaxy 3 should b made.
Seems to be the unpopular opinion, but Galaxy 3. I personally think the open world design has run it course and another in the series would received worse. Galaxy 3 in the other hand I think could have a bunch more implementation and improvements to that formula given modern hardware.
Honestly Galaxy 3.
I played Mario Odyssey once and never again.
But i still return to the Galaxys to this day.
Just imagine how good a new Galaxy title would be if they overhauled the control scheme
odyssey 2, preferably functionally similar to odyssey 1 but with more gimmicks (riding yoshi, different playable characters with their own sets of abilities, unlockable abilities/skill tree, etc.) and/or wildy new and unique captures
Mario 65
Luigi 64
Mario: Execute Order 66
K-Kill the younglings?!
koopalings\*
Eh, they’ve been doing that for over thirty years.
3 Days until Mario steals your liver! Wahoo!
And how long does it take for Luigi to return it?
2 days
K
3-5 business days
Not only the koopamen, but the koopawomen, and the koopachildren.
Toadlings
people love their comment threads dont they?
Letsago
this is all reddit is now
MAMA-MIA!
I feel for that hoax too, back in 1997! The one where you walk around the tree in front of the castle, collect every coin in the game, ride the volcano merry-go-round fifty times, then talk to Yoshi, and Luigi jumps out of the waterfall to meet you!
Waluigi 64
Wario 64
That was in the DS.
God, I wanted to unlock Waluigi in SM64DS so bad.
Everyone’s gangster until the Mario game starts speaking latin
Luigi's Tiny Home
You mean, Mario 128
Or wonderboy: the sacred sorcery...which I'm making on scratch...
That's Pikmin, Sunshine and Galaxy.
Mario 69
Waluigi 69
NO. NO. F*CK NO. WONDER BOY THE SACRED SORCERY. 4P MULTIPLAYER WITH ALL WONDER BOYS AND GIRLS. NO. F*CKING UNHOLY (that's a joke) JOKES
Nice!
I want Mario 62: The prequel to Super Mario 63.
Do you eat glue? (reference don't kill me)
I was coming here to request Mario64 2, happy to see it immediately lol
I would prefer a prequel, Mario 32 perhaps
still waiting for super mario 5-63
Odyssey 2. Galaxy was a cool concept, but they already went back to that well. I'd love to see what they could do with another go at the Odyssey formula.
I feel like there’s a couple new things you could do on the switch power wise that you couldn’t do on the Wii.
But many more mew things to do with Odyssey
Mew
The 151st pokemon
Like?
I don't have many ideas but I feel like there would be sense Galaxy has been tried twice in different ways and Odyssey has only been done once so not only can they apply old ideas to new things they also still have more room for new ideas to try
You just said your last statement but longer.
Yeah, but I think we have enough Galaxy for now. Maybe after an Odyssey 2, but we already have a sequel to Galaxy.
They could keep the formula exactly the same, just add new things to mind control and it would be great. If they ever did a Odyssey 2, the likely won't go this route, but like how Pauline is in one stage, it would be interesting to visit other characters in their own stages. Like visit Wario at Wario Inc, Princess Daisy in Sarasaland, meet any of the kings from Super Mario 3. The first game already went to the moon. So the observatory isn't out of the question. Or go further, as Samus is canonical to the Mario universe.
How about the island where DK lives? That could be fun.
Reunite but as friends.
About the last sentence: As if Mario had a coherent canon. Also a cameo doesn't build a canonical connection.
Super Mario Galaxy Odyssey mix both. and add a Kart level.
Super Mario: A Space Odyssey
I’m inclined to agree but they also went back to odyssey with things like bowsers fury and super mario 3d world, which were both done excellently imo. tbh i think i just want a whole new game, not because i didn’t like the owners, but because they have proved they can handle a new concept and excel with it, so something new would be even better (hopefully)
Odyssey with actual fulfilling stars. None of those crappy filler moons
I don’t know why everyone complains about this, I had literally no problem with the filler moons. It’s really only bothersome if you are going for 100%. I think it’s great that it basically has a “choose your own difficulty” where you only need a certain amount, so if you want to challenge yourself for a tough moon you can, or if you want you can get some easier ones instead
A world crafted with 8 unique stars will give you a better gameplay then a map filled with 50 moons scatered all around.
Ok well I enjoyed the shit out of Odyssey and so did a lot of other people, so maybe that’s just your personal preference and comparing it to the older games instead of just taking this game as it is
Well, think of how many points a moon has. Two, right? Now think of how many a star has: Five. That’s 2.5x more points. I hope now you understand why they’re so great
I’m sort of 50/50. I enjoyed most of it but the last 50-100 were tedious. The Toadette moons offered nothing
I loved the toadette moons. It felt like an achievement system
That SOUNDS right, and yet this is the very first time that I feel a Collectathon Mario game is **fun** to play. Mario 64 was in the genre's infancy so a lot could could be forgiven, but by the time Mario Sunshine came out we already had plenty of better games that felt a lot better to play, from the high-profile Spyro games to even smaller titles like that Toy Story 2 game. Sunshine had no excuse to be so badly executed as it was, for being the successor of the game that invented the genre. I also found Galaxy a slog to play through. They insisted on kicking you out of a level every time you collected something, reshuffling the level time after time and destroying whatever sense of exploration I might have had (this is a problem for the other titles too, but by Galaxy's era I have no idea why they couldn't have that sorted out yet so it's even more glaring), and in general behind their gimmick the places you explore feel unimaginative and even depressing to hang out in. The occasional dark sky is fine, but Galaxy definitely lacked the variety of settings that other Mario games have. I skipped Galaxy 2 because I didn't see the point. Say what you will about Odyssey, but it's the first time EVER in my long gamer career that started back on the NES that I can honestly say a Mario game is the best kind of Collectathon on the market, present or past. Maybe 8 unique stars have the potential to actually be better designed but OH BOY they really haven't lived up to that potential before Odyssey.
The movement was so good, why didn’t they use it :(
Odyssey controls are just too good, the Cappy movement makes me feel like a boss
Super Mario Galactic Odyssey Odyssey movement, Cappy, capturing enemies but you’re on planetoids. Some galaxies are kingdom sized with tons of stars and then there are some smaller Galaxy 1/2 sized galaxies. Both can mess around with planetoids and gravity manipulation And maybe X and Y could each individually control Cappy and luma for spin jump. It would be cute seeing luma carry Cappy around too
Dont forget about the most important thing! _changing the goddamn A button to the only interact button and not another button for jump_
Nintendo really do need to upgrade their control schemes, double buttons provide no benefit.
It's such a great game. I missed out on playing 64 and thought that I would have about the same experience with Odyssey and I absolutely did.
Sunshine 2
You answered the trick question correctly
This is the correct answer
Put on your sunglasses cause it’s VACAAATIIIOOOONNN TIIIIIIMMMMEEE!
It’s vacationin’ time!
Came here to post this
naw mario 64 ds 2
Mario 64 DS was honestly amazing
Nintendo: lol no
Odyssey 2
Galaxy 1 and 2 for that matter were/are may favorite games of all time. I have such great nestlogia for them and revisit them once a year. That being said, odyssey was just as phenomenal, and deserves a sequel, so I agree.
Nestlogia?
Nostalgia* Sorry for making the agregious mistake, that is a typo. Thank you so much for pointing out this major spelling error. I present you this trophy for this incredible achievement. 👍
Only a trophy? This dude/dudette deserves this year's Nobel prize. Incredible work, good sir/mam.
Good point. I hereby nominat u/NameOfNoSignificance for the Nobel prize of grammar.
Had no clue what you were trying to write. 🤷🏽♀️
I'm sure that was the case. /s Dis you? https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/wsahmf/why_are_you_on_reddit_right_now/ikzg6kv?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share&context=3
Some people just pride themselves on being annoying
Yeah it's the feeling birds get when they think back to being a baby bird in their nest and playing wii games with the other chicks.
I haven't even played Galaxy 2 yet
Do it
uh uh
Either - as long as Galaxy comes with full camera control this time.
I'm trying to 100% galaxy on the switch and that's the one thing i really can't stand about it, I'm never able to see what I need to. Not even the camera for N64 annoyed me this badly.
Yeah, agreed. I got about half way before giving up in frustration. We're spoilt by modern 3D games that always give full camera control with a right stick.
I love galaxy, but I need odyssey 2
Galaxy 3. Everything was grandiose in the Galaxy series that it made my kid and adult brains explode with joy. So over the top, so cinematic, it was awesome
Beautifully said
Plus rosalina! Perhaps!
The entire soundtrack was kickin
100% Odyssey 2
A new Mario and Luigi game
Damn between a Mario and Luigi on the Switch and Odyssey 2 would be such a tough call for me. Fucking adore that series but only one is realistic probably.
Space themed odyssey 2
that would be galaxy 3
Nooooooo. Galaxy is linear start to finish levels with a bunch of upside down small planet shit. This person is asking for a darkest side of the moon odyssey.
I think this would be the best option maybe. But the linear nature of galaxy packed with interesting level design made it such a popular game.
How about Mario Sunshine 2?
3D World 2
3D World 2: 4D World
It's About Time
Stfu you pun master!
So 3D Land 3?
9D Land
Super Mario sunshine
I'm surprised Fludd isn't just a standard Mario powerup at this point. No need for a whole game.
million% Odyssey 2
Odyssey 2 it’s not even a debate in my head. I loved odyssey so much. I haven’t that much fun playing Mario since 64.
3d world 2
3d World 2
So 3D Universe since it went from Land to World so now Universe
Make them as one game, super Mario galaxy with cappy.
Mario Galatic Odyssey would be a dope title
Galaxy 3
Super Mario RPG 2
This is the true answer.
Super Mario Galaxy 3: A Second Odyssey
Galaxy 3 without question
Galaxy 3
galaxy 3
Team Galaxy 3
Galaxy 3. Maybe regularly switch between Mario and Luigi because they would be using e. Gadd's inventions.
No question. Mariokart 9.
This is a really hard decision but galaxy 3
Too hard I can't decide
Hotel Mario 2
Galaxy 3. The children have had their time, but now it’s time for the men to have their turn. Just kidding lol. Odyssey was really cool, but I think that it’s about time that Galaxy gets to have a comeback.
Galaxy 3
Easily Galaxy 3
Galaxy 3, I just think that would be more fun
Galaxy 3 Gang RISE UP
Galaxy 3. Galaxy 2 is one of my favorite games of all time, with 1 being not very far behind. To be honest, I don't really care that much about captures in retrospect. Gravity however, was a very fun mechanic to me that I would love to see return as the main gimmick.
galaxy 3 THINK OF HOW FUCKING AMAZING THE SOUNDTRACK WOULD BE
Galaxy 3, but really I don't care. I trust Nintendo.
Super Mario Galaxy 3 sounds really good
Galaxy 3
Super Mario 3D Universe
Galaxy 3
Odyssey 2, galaxy was a fun game but I think I'd rather see what they would do in an Odyssey sequel
Where’s Wario and Waluigi’s Slumlord Adventure?!
thats a point
Galaxy. All the way. Still have the first two on the Wii but I don’t think they work anymore
Odyssey 2. Every. Goddamn. Time.
Oddesy 2. Galaxy already got it’s time to shine, It’s time we show odyssey some love.
galaxy 3
Galaxy 3
Mario sunshine 2
neither, something unique should be made
I feel like Mario is headed towards a fully open world, which I personally think would be super cool if it’s like Bowsers fury
Galaxy 3 hands down
Galaxy 3 without a doubt. Its just one of those series that should be wrapped up in a trilogy, with a bow on top. And if they do ever make Galaxy 3, I hope they add Birdo since they added Yoshi in 2.
Galaxy 3.
Galaxy 3, though I’d be fine if they didn’t since they hated making galaxy 2 apparently
Galaxy 3
Galaxy 3
Galaxy 3, no contest. Bring back 1ups though. I need to hoard them like an addict
Both have their merits. Gakaxy 3 would have a lot more variety, but more linearity, most likely. Odyssey 2 would have more substantial, open levels, but fewer of them. I personally would prefer Galaxy 3 because I think Odyssey doesn't do as good a job of making main objectives feel satisfying, plus I think that the Galaxy games have some of the best bosses in 3D Mario.
Perfectly said. Main objectives in Odyssey are simple because a lot of the times you can run past everything because of openness of the world.
Odyssey 2, if they really branch out with their worlds. Deeper, more ambitious themes. Sometimes the locations in Odyssey just felt generic.
Odyssey with a hub world instead of the balloon. Take the best and mix it with the best. More unlockables and more secrets, collect everything and get a different final boss.
Galaxy 3
Galaxy, only because I dig the whole outer space thing more
Paper Mario. But a return to form.
Super Mario Sunshine 2 instead plz
Odyssey and it’s not even close, haven’t had that much fun playing Nintendo since Sunshine
Galaxy 3
BOTW 2
Isn’t that coming out next year already though?
They’ve said that before
Mario 65
Galaxy 3. Open world is just never going to work for me. Not in odyssey not in breath of the wild.
Odyssey is trash in comparison to Galaxy 2, facts. Galaxy 2 just has way more galaxies aka kingdoms to explore. And the gameplay is p similar so Galaxy 2 easily wins which means Galaxy 3 should b made.
Galaxy 3, no contest.
Seems to be the unpopular opinion, but Galaxy 3. I personally think the open world design has run it course and another in the series would received worse. Galaxy 3 in the other hand I think could have a bunch more implementation and improvements to that formula given modern hardware.
Galaxy 3! Odyssey was a huge disappointment to me. Smooth jazz in a Mario game? I’ll pass.
Honestly Galaxy 3. I played Mario Odyssey once and never again. But i still return to the Galaxys to this day. Just imagine how good a new Galaxy title would be if they overhauled the control scheme
Super Mario Sunshine 2
"both, both is good,"
Odyssey 2 by a mile.
tough call
odyssey 2, preferably functionally similar to odyssey 1 but with more gimmicks (riding yoshi, different playable characters with their own sets of abilities, unlockable abilities/skill tree, etc.) and/or wildy new and unique captures
Odyssey 2 with a port announcement of galaxy 2 :)
You get neither unfortunately
Odyssey 2
Odyssey 2, no question
Put Yoshi on Odyssey 2 and I'm sold.
Odyssey 2
Odyssey 2, but only because I feel like Galaxy was so perfected that there’s not as much new stuff that could be done with it compared to odyssey
Either one with optimized controls for the switch, their current counterparts on switch could both do better in that department
Odyssey 2
How about both as one game?
for Mario Galaxy 2 to be ported the 3D all stars
Oddysey
Purple pill